reflections on the birth of a nation (1915)


After reading Linda William's writing: "Race, Melodrama, and The Birth of a Nation (1915)" I understood that there was much more going on alongside racism and white supremacy. There are the undertones, seemingly less important that the major injustices but equally important to recognize. 


Thomas Dixon was very anti-Tom storyline, as Williams addressed in the content. He created African Americans as an individual with unruly features and carried other attributes as a, "Hyper-masculine rapist who can only be stoped by lynching" (244 Williams). The level of aggressive exaggeration that was employed by Dixon clearly made him a white supremacist, lacking in the understanding of man as equal.


Williams wrote about how Dixon created the complex of African American men. She notes: "The constant threat of rape was not simply a rationalization used to obscure the real function of keeping black men in their place, it was also a way to keep white women in their place." I had never thought of this before but studying history in high school I do recall that often men were depicted this way. There is a new level of understanding of marginalized groups being kept in their place.  Williams goes on to quote Hall (1993,  153): "The 'fear of rape, like the threat of lynching, served to keep the subordinate group in a state of anxiety and fear'". According to understanding, there are consequences, very serious consequences; sexual assault and death put in place to keep people from 'standing inside the margins' so to speak. 



Comments

  1. I didn't watch the entire film but I also realized the "hyper-masculine rapist" trait through some scenes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Love the post and I totally agree with a'lot of your points!

    ReplyDelete
  3. You put this all very eloquently, and I agree with you. In addition, the way that this film was made lent to deep seated hatred through its aesthetics and portrayals of characters.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I teach this film because I think that its important to think about the ways that the doctrine of white supremacy underlines so much of our cinematic language within narrative cinema thanks to the influence of this film. Hopefully, we are doing some reckoning with this legacy in the social fabric of our culture right now.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment